Hi,
That is strange, my guess is that when the cache was re-created, and the cropping was disabled, then the plugin cache + the page cache may have memorized the uncropped versions.
The only thing that should limit the cropping is, if the image is smaller than the cropping size (I don’t think that is your case), or if there is no permission to write the files – however that is fine as well, since there were files cropped.
Can you pelase try the following:
– Make sure that the image cropping option is enabled on all related posts pro instances you have: https://i.imgur.com/QEt1Srv.png
– Also, turn off the related posts pro cache: https://i.imgur.com/lANvUtC.png
– Then clear all site/cloudflare caches, and reload the pages via CTRL + F5 buttons
This will prevent the ‘double’ caching, as the wp rocket cache is sufficient to handle that. If this was the issue, then the images should start appearing as the cropped versions.