1. The ‘at least one match..’ should work in this case. I suspect that you might not have the latest version of the plugin installed, as I recall there was a change in this logic in the recent 5 or 6 releases. Please make sure that the latest release is installed, version 4.11.5.
I’ve tried to replicate this behavior on my test environment, but I was not able to. I’ve made a category and post tag filter, and then choosen a category and all the tags – but only the posts that matched both at least one tag and the chosen category was displayed, correctly. I guess the update will solve this then.
Sidebar widget issue fix
A possible solution is to maybe use this plugin, which enables shortcodes as sidebar widgets. Then you could place the plugin shortcode there.
If you like my products, don't forget to rate them on codecanyon :)