Hey, thanks for the quick reply.
I didn't change back to an older plugin. I'm not sure what happened? I didn't realize that I had to keep Search in Pages/Posts selected. Perhaps I'll remove that option so it automatically searches in posts and pages and users can't deselect it so they don't return empty results. Thanks for the clarification on it.
With the $, it's weird. Now it's showing. It wasn't showing before. I'm going to test everything on the live site (what you were working on was a dev site) and see if I get the same results. Thanks for your help!